What’s the smartest first move: refinance the car or finance major dental work?
I’m in a situation that a lot of people quietly end up in. For years, I put my family first: raising kids, helping with college, lending money when someone needed it. While all that was happening, my own needs slipped to the bottom of the list — especially my teeth.
Now everything has come due at once. I urgently need full-mouth dental work (All-on-4), and at the same time I’m planning to refinance my car loan. Both things are important, both affect my finances and my credit, and I’m trying to figure out what I should do first.
My credit score is around 750, which is solid. The idea I initially got was:
– Refinance the auto loan first to get a lower payment
– That should improve my debt-to-income ratio (DTI)
– Then apply for a personal loan or dental financing for the All-on-4 treatment
On paper, that sounds logical. Lower car payment → better DTI → better chances of approval for the dental loan.
But there’s a big problem: time.
When you refinance a car, your old auto loan is paid off and a new one appears on your report. That almost always causes a temporary dip in your credit score. It can take 30–60 days (sometimes longer) for your credit profile to stabilize after the new loan reports.
My teeth, on the other hand, may not hold out that long. Waiting a couple of months isn’t just uncomfortable — it might be medically risky. And if my score drops too much right after the refinance, I could end up paying more for dental financing or even struggling to be approved for the amount I need.
On top of that, my DTI isn’t terrible right now. I’m not overloaded with debt; I’m just facing two big financial decisions at the same time, both with deadlines.
So the real question becomes:
– Do I prioritize my health and get the dental work financed first?
– Or do I optimize my numbers and refinance the car first, hoping it helps with loan terms?
—
How refinancing can affect your credit in the short term
Refinancing your auto loan usually means:
1. A hard inquiry on your credit report
2. Closing one installment account (the old car loan)
3. Opening a new installment account (the refinanced loan)
Short-term impact can include:
– A small drop in your score from the new inquiry
– A temporary decrease in your average account age
– A bit of volatility while the credit bureaus update everything
Over time, a lower monthly payment and reliably on-time payments often help your score. But that’s a long game. If you need to apply for another loan within weeks, that short-term dip can matter.
Because your current score is already around 750, you’re in a good range. The harder question isn’t, “Will a refinance totally destroy my credit?” (it won’t), but “Is now the right moment to shake up my credit profile when I’m about to apply for a large medical/dental loan?”
—
Why urgent dental work may need to come first
All-on-4 is not a minor procedure. When your teeth are already in bad shape, waiting another month or two can mean:
– More pain
– Higher risk of infection
– Potential for bone loss, which can complicate or delay treatment
– Possibly even higher total cost if your condition worsens
Unlike refinancing, which is a financial optimization, this is about health, function, and quality of life. That alone is a powerful argument for making the dental work the first priority.
On top of that:
– A 750 credit score is already high enough for many lenders to offer decent terms.
– A single new loan (for dental work) may not hurt you as much as you fear, especially if your overall DTI is reasonable and you have a decent payment history.
In other words, you might be in a good enough position right now to qualify for the dental financing you need — and *then* look at the car refinance after everything settles.
—
Rethinking the sequence: an alternative strategy
Instead of automatically following the “refi first” logic, consider flipping the order with a more targeted plan:
1. Get prequalified or explore options for dental financing first
– Many lenders allow soft pulls initially, which don’t hurt your score.
– Dental clinics often work with multiple financing partners; you can compare offers.
– You’ll see whether your current 750 score already gets you acceptable terms.
2. Lock in the dental solution as soon as possible
– Once you find a workable financing option, prioritize getting the treatment.
– Your health and comfort improve, and the problem stops getting worse.
3. Only then, evaluate the auto refinance
– After the dental loan is in place and your budget is clear, you can shop for refi deals.
– A lower car payment after the fact can help you manage all obligations comfortably.
This order protects what’s most urgent (your mouth and health), while still leaving room to optimize your finances afterward.
—
Don’t overestimate the DTI benefit of refinancing
It’s easy to assume that refinancing the car will dramatically improve your DTI and therefore your chances of getting a dental loan. But in many cases:
– The monthly payment reduction is helpful, but not massive
– Your overall DTI may only improve marginally
– Lenders look at more than just DTI: payment history, length of credit history, score range, and stability all matter
If your DTI “isn’t really high” right now, the marginal benefit of a slightly lower car payment may be smaller than the risk of:
– Taking a short-term hit to your score
– Adding complexity to your credit report right before applying for medical financing
A solid 750 score and manageable existing payments can already be enough to qualify you. In that context, preserving your clean, stable profile until after you secure the dental financing can be the safer move.
—
How to protect your credit while doing both
If you need *both* the dental work and the refinance in a relatively short window, you can still minimize damage by being methodical:
1. Limit the number of hard inquiries
– For dental loans, try to work with providers that offer prequalification via soft pull.
– For auto refinance, rate shop within a tight window (often 14–45 days) so inquiries count as one for scoring purposes.
2. Avoid additional new debt or cards
– Don’t open new credit cards or take out other loans “just in case.”
– Keep other financial activity quiet and predictable while you handle these two big items.
3. Pay everything on time, without exception
– One late payment does far more damage than a refinance or a new loan.
– Set up automatic payments or reminders for all current bills.
4. Keep credit card balances low
– Utilization is a major part of your score.
– If possible, pay down revolving balances before applying for dental financing. That can further offset any concerns about DTI.
—
Practical steps to decide your exact next move
Here’s a simple, structured way to move forward:
1. Confirm your current numbers
– Check your exact DTI (total monthly debt payments divided by gross monthly income).
– Confirm your current FICO score from a reputable source.
2. Talk to the dental provider’s financing options
– Ask what typical scores and DTIs they approve.
– Ask about in-house plans, third-party lenders, and whether they run a soft or hard pull.
3. Run a “what if” budget scenario
– Estimate what your All-on-4 monthly payment might be.
– Add it to your current car payment and other debts.
– Ask yourself: Can I reasonably afford this without refi? If yes, you’re in a stronger position to prioritize health.
4. If financing for dental work seems tight but possible
– You might still prioritize the dental loan, then aggressively seek out a refi afterward to reduce total monthly pressure.
5. If you’re denied dental financing with your current setup
– Then a refinance *might* become a necessary prerequisite to improve DTI — but that decision should come only after you’ve tried with your current profile and understand the exact reasons for denial.
—
Balancing emotion, urgency, and math
It’s important to acknowledge the emotional side of this. You’ve spent years putting others first, and now you’re being forced to choose between your health and your financial optimization. That’s a heavy weight.
But when you strip away the guilt and anxiety, a few things stand out clearly:
– Dental issues are progressive and often get worse if postponed.
– Your current credit profile is not bad; it’s actually strong.
– A refinance is about getting better terms, not solving an emergency.
When two priorities collide, you protect the one that can’t safely wait. In your case, that leans strongly toward securing the dental treatment first, especially if lenders are already likely to view your 750 score and current DTI favorably.
—
When it might make sense to refi first
There *are* edge cases where refinancing the car first could be justified, for example if:
– Your current car payment is extremely high relative to your income
– Your DTI is already borderline (e.g., above 45–50%) and lenders are signaling that it’s a problem
– You’re at risk of missing auto payments soon unless that payment is reduced
In those scenarios, stabilizing the car loan may actually protect your credit by preventing missed payments. But from what you’ve described — reasonable DTI, good score, and urgency around your teeth — that doesn’t sound like your exact situation.
—
The bottom line
With a credit score around 750, a not-too-high DTI, and urgent need for All-on-4 dental work, the more rational order for most people in your position is:
1. Pursue dental financing first while your credit profile is clean and strong.
2. Complete or at least lock in the treatment plan and funding.
3. Once that’s secured, look at refinancing your auto loan to ease long-term monthly pressure.
That way, you:
– Protect your health and avoid deterioration of your dental condition
– Use your current strong credit profile for the most critical loan
– Still leave room to optimize your finances afterward with a refi
You’ve spent years taking care of everyone else. Prioritizing essential medical and dental care now isn’t selfish; it’s responsible. Once that’s under control, you can turn back to fine-tuning your budget and interest rates.