Working in One State and Living in Another: Are You Paying Double Taxes?
When you live in one state and earn your paycheck in another, it’s easy to panic the first time you see how much is being withheld from your paycheck. If you’re in a situation like living in Maryland and working in Delaware, it can feel like your entire check is disappearing – especially when coworkers seem to be taking home a lot more than you.
But in most cases you are not actually being “double taxed” in the way people fear. The rules are a bit more complicated and depend on where you live, where you work, and how state tax credits are handled.
Let’s break down what’s likely happening, why your take‑home pay is so low, and what you should do to fix or understand it.
—
1. Living in Maryland, Working in Delaware: Basic Idea
You generally owe state income tax to:
– The state where you live (your state of residence), and sometimes also
– The state where you work (your work state), on income earned there.
Many states avoid truly taxing the same income twice by:
– Letting the state where you live give you a credit for taxes you paid to the state where you work, or
– Having a reciprocity agreement (where one state agrees not to tax residents of the other in certain situations).
In your case:
– You live in Maryland
– You work in Delaware
Maryland and Delaware do not have a broad, simple reciprocity agreement like some neighboring states do. That means:
– Delaware can tax the income you earn while working there.
– Maryland can still tax you as a resident on all your income, but Maryland will typically give a credit for the Delaware tax you’ve already paid, so you don’t fully pay tax twice on the same dollars when you file your return.
—
2. Withholding vs. Actual Tax: Why Your Paycheck Looks So Small
What comes out of your paycheck each week is called withholding. It’s not a final tax bill; it’s an estimate your employer sends to the government on your behalf. At the end of the year, when you file your tax returns, the actual tax is calculated, and:
– If too much was withheld, you get a refund
– If too little was withheld, you owe more
So if your paycheck looks like this:
– Gross pay for 25 hours: about $360
– Net (take-home) pay: around $190
You’re losing almost half your pay in withholdings. That seems high for this pay level, so it’s important to check what exactly is being taken out.
Typical withholdings you might see:
– Federal income tax
– Social Security tax
– Medicare tax
– State income tax (possibly for one or both states)
– Local or county tax (for some states, including Maryland)
– Benefits (health insurance, retirement contributions, etc., if you’re enrolled)
If your coworkers are “almost double” your take-home pay, one of these might be true:
– They claimed more allowances or different filing status on their tax forms, so less is being withheld.
– They live in a different state with different tax rules.
– They don’t have certain benefits or deductions coming out of their checks.
– There could be a mistake in your paperwork or payroll setup.
—
3. Should You Have Taxes Withheld for Both States?
In cross-state situations, it’s possible that:
– The work state (Delaware) must withhold its state tax.
– Your home state (Maryland) might also be withholding, especially if your employer’s system is set up that way or if you filled out your forms in a certain way.
But even if both states are withholding, you are still supposed to avoid true double taxation at filing time because:
– When you file your Maryland resident return, you can usually claim a credit for taxes paid to another state (Delaware).
– This means Maryland reduces your Maryland tax bill by the amount you already paid Delaware (up to certain limits).
So you might be “over-withheld” during the year but not truly taxed twice in the final calculation. Over-withholding just means a bigger refund later – not that the government keeps all of it permanently.
Still, unnecessary double withholding hurts your *cash flow* right now, and you have every reason to want to reduce it to a reasonable level.
—
4. Why Your Co‑Workers Take Home More Than You
If your coworkers are taking home nearly twice what you are on similar hours and gross pay, consider:
1. Where do they live?
– If they live in Delaware, they only deal with Delaware tax on that income, not Maryland’s resident tax. Their situation is simpler.
– If they live in a low-tax area, their net pay may be naturally higher.
2. What did they put on their tax forms?
– On federal and state withholding forms (like the W-4 and state equivalents), they might claim:
– Single vs. Married
– Additional withholding vs. none
– Fewer dependents vs. more dependents
More allowances or certain filing choices can result in less tax being taken out per paycheck.
3. Do they have fewer deductions?
– If they’re not contributing to retirement accounts or paying for employer health insurance, their paycheck might look larger, but they may be missing out on benefits or long‑term savings.
4. Experience vs. new hire factor
– Sometimes employers misclassify a new employee’s tax setup until the right forms are processed, which can cause extra withholding at the beginning.
—
5. What You Should Look At Right Now
To understand whether you’re being treated fairly, do this:
1. Check your pay stub closely
Look at the line items and write them down:
– Federal income tax withheld
– Social Security
– Medicare
– State income tax (note whether it says MD, DE, or both)
– Any local or county taxes
– Other deductions (insurance, union dues, retirement, etc.)
2. Verify your address and state residency with HR or payroll
Make sure your employer has you listed as a Maryland resident who works in Delaware, not the other way around or as something odd.
3. Review the tax forms you filled out when you were hired
You likely filled out:
– A federal W‑4 form
– A state withholding form (possibly Maryland and/or Delaware versions)
Check:
– Filing status (single, married, head of household)
– Whether you asked for “extra” money to be withheld
– Whether you selected a nonresident option for Delaware or similar
4. Compare with a coworker
If you’re comfortable, ask a trusted coworker who earns similar wages:
– How much federal and state tax is coming out of their check
– Whether they live in Delaware or Maryland
– What they remember choosing on their tax forms
This won’t give you a complete legal answer, but it will help you spot obvious differences.
—
6. Are You Actually Being “Ripped Off”?
In most cases, no one is deliberately cheating you; the system is just complicated, and payroll departments default to conservative (higher) withholding to avoid you owing a lot at the end of the year.
However, it’s possible that:
– The wrong state is being used as your primary tax state.
– Taxes are being withheld for both states when it’s not necessary in that way.
– Your withholding elections are overly aggressive (too much taken out every period).
The harsh weekly impact – going from 360 gross to 190 net – is often a combination of:
– Federal tax
– Social Security and Medicare
– State tax
– Possibly local or county tax
– Plus any benefits you signed up for
That total can feel like half your paycheck is gone, especially at lower income levels.
The real question is not just “How much is being taken out?” but:
– “Is the *right amount* being taken out, for the *right states*?”
– “Will I get most of that back as a refund at tax time?”
—
7. How Filing Your Taxes Will Work
At tax time, if you:
– Live in Maryland
– Work in Delaware
You can generally expect to file:
1. A Delaware nonresident income tax return (to report the income earned working in Delaware and pay tax on that income).
2. A Maryland resident tax return (to report all your income, but claim a credit for the tax you already paid to Delaware).
That credit usually keeps you from being taxed twice on the same wages. It doesn’t necessarily put every dollar back in your pocket, but it stops the worst of double taxation.
If too much has been withheld from either state during the year, you can get part of it back as a refund when you file.
—
8. How to Reduce Withholding (If Appropriate)
If you find withholding is higher than necessary, you can usually adjust it:
1. Update your federal W‑4
– Use the official worksheet or an estimator to see how to reduce federal withholding to match your actual expected tax.
– Don’t drop it unrealistically low; owing a big bill and penalties later hurts more.
2. Ask HR/payroll about state withholding flexibility
– Clarify which state(s) they are witholding for and whether any changes are allowed given you live in Maryland and work in Delaware.
– In some cases, you may be able to adjust the amount withheld for Maryland if it’s clearly excessive.
3. Project your yearly income
– If your income is relatively low for the year, your effective tax rate might not be as high as your paycheck suggests.
– Over-withholding at lower incomes is common and fixable with adjusted forms.
—
9. When to Get Professional Help
If:
– Your pay stubs show both MD and DE taxes being withheld heavily, and
– Your take-home pay is far lower than those around you, and
– You’re not sure what forms to change without making it worse,
it can be worth consulting a tax professional or a knowledgeable preparer for at least one tax season. They can:
– Review your situation as a Maryland resident with Delaware wages.
– Help you correctly claim the credit for taxes paid to Delaware.
– Show you how to adjust your future withholding so that you’re not losing unnecessary cash each week.
Even a one-time walkthrough can teach you enough to handle it yourself in the future.
—
10. Key Takeaways
– Working in a different state from where you live can make your paycheck look strange, but it usually does not mean you’re permanently taxed twice on the same income.
– In your Maryland-Delaware situation, you might see heavy withholding from one or both states, but your Maryland tax return should give you credit for tax paid to Delaware.
– A net of about 190 on 360 gross sounds high in terms of total deductions, so you should:
– Review your pay stub line by line.
– Confirm your residence and tax forms with HR or payroll.
– Adjust your withholding if it’s clearly more aggressive than necessary.
– You may not be getting “screwed over,” but you may be over-withheld – which you can often correct and later recover through refunds.
The bottom line: check your pay stub, verify your tax setup with your employer, and make sure you understand how Maryland and Delaware taxes interact at filing time. That’s the best way to tell whether this is normal for your situation or something that needs to be fixed.